"5th November
Daylight brought on a terrific bombardment from the Turks and our Infantry attacked Khuwilfeh. With regards, this is a fair sized hill and commanding position, and we had a good view of the Infantry attacking. Both sides working their artillery very hard. Then as the shelling ceased a tremendous cheer went up and our Infantry rushed the position. The Turks fled. The Turks made a determined counter attack without result – The Canterbury Mounteds and the Wellington Mounteds got the hottest part. Fritz gave us some bombs and some shells dropped among the horses.
The Turks wanted this hill so they made another attempt, the Wellington Mounteds and our own 11th Squadron NAMR were put in to assist and the attack was beaten off.
Our horses had had no water for thirty hours, rations have not reached us and small parties took water bottles about five miles and filled them. Quartermaster’s branch had much difficulty getting rations to us in the darkness.
No sign of relieving force and at 10 pm the Brigadier conferred with commanding officers and we sent the horses back for a drink. They had to go about 12 miles. All but the machine gun packhorses went – we felt quite lonely without them."
George's particular hell would have been his evacuation from the battlefield to medical support many miles to the rear. If he was lucky, he may well have been supported by fellow troopers and then been able to ride back on his own mount the 12 miles to the Casualty Clearing Station. However he may have been among the many more seriously wounded that had to endure being stretched out by Camel Cacolets. This particular form of transportation of the wounded across the desert was a ride of swaying pain. Stretchers were slung each side of a camel, and a slow two miles an hour trek across burning sands to medical support was a feat of endurance that many did not survive. Then the CCS would have been just the start for George and the other seriously wounded. Perhaps days of intense pain as Cacolets, or sledge or sandcarts carried these men to the rail head at El Arish. Once there a further tedious journey by train across the Sinai Desert to Egypt, a bumpy lurching trip to Cairo. The trip from battlefield to hospital could take a week.

Cacolet Camels carrying wounded from the battlefield.
Active Service Casualty forms show that George required extensive hospitalisation for his shrapnel wound and although he was re-posted a number of times back to service, the wound dogged him for the rest of his service in the NZMR, indeed caused him much pain for the rest of his life.
George served one year, one hundred and seventy three days on overseas service. In total two years and thirty six days for his country.
What can be said about George is not what is written within official records but in the final lines of the letter George’s daughter wrote when she sent in his photographs and records:
“…My Dad leased a farm and worked very hard on it until his back injury caused his retirement. I have much to thank him for, as he taught me godly principles and loyalty.
Thank you again. Jean Shannon.”
Footnote:
In this modern age of electronic communication it appears that the holders of the keys to our countries history have taken another step backwards rather than forwards. Until recently the National Archives of New Zealand allowed New Zealanders the opportunity to apply in writing for military records, but now this government department insists that members of the public must first apply in writing to make an appointment for a particular record and then appear at their offices in person to be able to access and read them.
The cost for families to travel to Wellington to view such records can be prohibitive, and many decide not to make the effort on perhaps a flimsy bit of hearsay from an old family letter or photograph – and the continuing line of knowledge is lost.
We must ask the question of why the inability of Archives New Zealand to provide electronic access and knowledge to all when our Australian cousins benefit from a wealth of information available online by such institutions as the Australian War Memorial in Canberra. Recently the AWM made available an additional source online with individual unit and company “War Diaries” accessible by just a few mouse clicks. This marvelous resource makes available Australian history for families, researchers and historians free of charge and instantaneous. Hats off to Australian initiatives and service to the public. It appears sadly the New Zealand bureaucrat just bumbles on – again.
|